Simon Goodwin

Oh Goodwin, just when i knew a high score was coming
because Adelaide were playing Melbourne he becomes injured. Not
gonna trade him because i have waters and maguire on the bench but
wish i hadn`t bought him. Got caught after his stunning pre season form.

the man's getting older not that sure he's going to have a year like last

mmmm great player and Im a crow through and through but not a good SC pick this year considering others that were available and more durable.

I got hammered last year with non durable players in Drummond, Stevie J and Chappy

learnt my lesson!

I think there's better options out there than Goodwin for that price - as the others are saying, on the older side.

should i trade him then? who could i trade him too?
My defence is as follows
Goddard, Goodwin, Hodge, Enright, Drummond, Kennelly, Ladson, Maguire and Waters.

Interesting, strong back line, maybe malcheski for a heap of cash, Carrazzo or Scottland. Carrots to think about

Although what I meant was not pick him from the start, I would not waste a trade on him now as you do have great cover in Waters and I dont think he will be out for long, its only a cork isn't it?

correct don't trade him now, is still a good player and will average well just may miss a week or two here and there.

Tony's comments were definitely more around picking him from the start. Now you have him don't trade him charlo he will still score well this year